COMPARISON REVIEW: Cleansers

I’ve seen these being compared to the Glossier milky jelly cleanser time and time again, so I decided to do a comparison review for you all👀
-
1. CeraVe - I think it was @gothamista who first said she found this cleanser comparable, or even a proper dupe for the glossier milky jelly. Other than the fact that they’re both super gentle on my skin, I find them to be extremely different from each other, especially texturally! This cleanser has always felt like a lotion to me. Think CeraVe PM moisturizer w a bit more slip & you have this. It has a VERY thin texture and a slippy, lotion-like feeling upon application which IMO, is very unlike milky jelly. It also always seems to leave what I think might be a (albeit softening) film on my skin after using it.
I do however love how gentle this is, but it does nothing to remove spf/makeup so it’s def a second step cleanser- and don’t even bother trying to remove your eye makeup w this! Nowhere near as powerful as milky jelly in that regard, and it could also sting.
-
2. E.L.F. Bounce Back Jelly Cleanser - the most texturally similar cleanser to milky jelly that I’ve come by thus far. I find this to be even MORE jelly than the milky jelly cleanser, as well as a tad bit thicker than Glossier’s formula. This removes eye makeup and even a full face with ease without stripping my skin. The two major differences worth mentioning: it has a pretty artificial coconut scent, but I personally don’t mind it. And if you have sensitive eyes, I’d be wary of opening them while using this to remove eye makeup just in case it might sting or cause irritation.
-
Overall I’m still obsessed with milky jelly and will continue to repurchase it time and time again, but the same can be said about all 3 of these cleansers since I use them interchangeably on a consistent basis.
Comments
Post a Comment